Request a Demo

    Could CI Scores be the Next Tradable Attribute?

    April 9, 2024
    In the dynamic world of grain trading, where every fraction of a cent matters, savvy grain merchandisers are constantly on the lookout for innovative strategies to maximize profits. One emerging strategy involves leveraging Carbon Intensity (CI) scores, an environmental metric gaining traction in agricultural markets worldwide. By considering CI scores for trading decisions, grain merchandisers can unlock unique arbitrage and other opportunities and stay ahead of the curve in a rapidly evolving industry.

    Register for our Upcoming Webinar:
    Unlocking the Biofuels Opportunity: Generating Value From Low-Carbon Feedstock 

    Understanding CI Scores
    To fully leverage merchandising opportunities, it is important to level-set on the concept of a CI score. The CI score quantifies the greenhouse gas emissions produced in generating a specific quantity of a commodity. It considers a range of factors, including cultivation practices, fertilizer use, transportation, and processing. A lower CI score indicates the production process has increased energy efficiency and emits less carbon, making the product more attractive in markets prioritizing sustainability. The increasing emphasis on sustainability and the introduction of carbon taxes and trading schemes in many states and territories have made the CI score a significant factor in the valuation of agricultural commodities. Products with lower CI scores may attract premium pricing or preferential market access. Consequently, for grain merchandisers, understanding the CI score of feedstocks, down to the field level, becomes critical in identifying and capitalizing on market disparities.

    For grain merchandisers, integrating CI scores into their trading strategies offers several compelling advantages. Here's how:

    1. Arbitrage Opportunities: Grain merchandisers can explore various arbitrage opportunities by leveraging the CI score of feedstocks, capitalizing on geographical, time-based, and process optimization disparities. Through geographical arbitrage, they can buy corn with lower CI scores in regions where it is undervalued and sell it at a premium in markets prioritizing sustainability. Time-based arbitrage allows merchandisers to benefit from evolving market preferences and regulations by buying low and selling high as demand for sustainable products grows. Additionally, by engaging in process optimization arbitrage, they can partner with producers focused on reducing the CI score through advanced farming techniques or technology, capitalizing on the evolving sustainability trends in supply chains.

    2. Market Differentiation: In an increasingly eco-conscious marketplace, consumers and businesses are prioritizing sustainable products. Corn with lower CI scores holds inherent value, appealing to buyers seeking to minimize their carbon footprint. By sourcing and marketing low-CI corn, merchandisers can differentiate their product offerings, command premium prices, and gain a competitive edge in the market.

    3. Risk Management: Environmental sustainability is increasingly becoming a regulatory and financial consideration for businesses across industries. By prioritizing low-CI feedstock in their procurement strategies, merchandisers can mitigate regulatory risks associated with carbon emissions and position themselves as responsible stewards of the environment. Additionally, by aligning with sustainability trends, merchandisers can future-proof their operations against evolving market preferences and regulatory requirements.

    4. Stakeholder Engagement: Embracing CI scores fosters transparency and accountability throughout the grain supply chain. Merchandisers can collaborate with farmers, processors, and other stakeholders to adopt practices that reduce carbon emissions and improve sustainability outcomes. This collaborative approach not only enhances brand reputation but also strengthens relationships with key partners, laying the foundation for long-term success.

    For grain merchandisers looking to take part in these arbitrage opportunities, a multi-faceted approach is essential:

    Market Research: Merchandisers must keep abreast of grain market trends, sustainability developments, regulatory updates, and policy shifts that influence the CI score's effect on feedstocks. Having the appropriate tools, technology, and partners is crucial for generating insights essential for success.

    Technological Investment: Leveraging technology for real-time tracking and management of CI scores, inventories, and market prices can provide a competitive edge in identifying arbitrage opportunities.

    Sustainability Partnerships: Building relationships with producers focused on sustainability may ensure access to corn with competitive CI scores.

    Risk Management: As with any arbitrage strategy, understanding and mitigating risks associated with market volatility, regulatory changes, and contract fulfillment is crucial.

    Utilizing a combination of advanced technologies including data collection platforms, satellite imagery, and machine learning, stakeholders in the agricultural sector can effectively capture CI scores for products like corn and soybeans. These technologies enable the comprehensive analysis of environmental impacts across the entire supply chain, enabling informed decision-making, transparency, and continuous improvement in sustainability practices.

    The integration of the Carbon Intensity (CI) score into the valuation of feedstock presents novel arbitrage opportunities for grain merchandisers. By capitalizing on the disparities created by varying CI scores across geographical locations, time, and production processes, merchandisers can unlock new profit avenues while contributing to the sustainability of the agricultural sector. However, success in this endeavor requires meticulous market research, technological support, strategic partnerships, and effective risk management. As the agricultural market continues to evolve towards sustainability, the ability to navigate and leverage CI scores will become an increasingly valuable skill for grain merchandisers. At Indigo Ag we have the tools and technology to provide Merchandisers with the data and insights they need to take advantage of these opportunities, laying the groundwork for a more transparent, resilient, and environmentally responsible grain trading ecosystem.

    Register for our Upcoming Webinar:
    Unlocking the Biofuels Opportunity: Generating Value From Low-Carbon Feedstock 

    This blog post is provided by Indigo Ag, Inc. (“Indigo”) for informational purposes only. Nothing herein should be construed as an investment recommendation, a commodity trading recommendation, or legal, tax, investment or accounting advice.